Skip to main content

Nest & Collapse Comments

Would really like to see the option of more deeply nested comments, along with the option to collapse all nested comments. (See how comments work on Substack.)
As it stands now, comments on Heartbeat are nested only 1 level deep, which can be quite confusing for more complex discussions.
In addition, the entire comment thread is now visible, which is also problematic in terms of reading ease with longer and more complex discussions.

7 comments

Log in to comment and vote

Comments7

  • Misty Dorman

    •

    Nov 5

    •

    Merged request

    •

    1 vote

    Hide comments on mobile

    I saw a completed feature request in here for correcting the number of hidden/collapsed comments/replies, but currently comments don't seem to be hidden on mobile. This makes threads' comment area really long to scroll if it has a lot of activity.

    • Misty Dorman

      •

      Aug 8, 2022

      How it looks on Facebook

    • Misty Dorman

      •

      Aug 8, 2022

      How it looks on Heartbeat desktop

  • Alex R

    •

    Nov 5

    •

    Merged request

    •

    6 votes

    Nest comments like Reddit

    I really like Reddit's nested structure with clickable lines and I think it's more clear too. Being able to bookmark comments is also good.

    I attached an example:

    This is a suggestion and I think the implementation is worth borrowing from.

    • Sarah Parker

      •

      Jan 7

      Super helpful. Facebook groups have this too

  • Doug Finkelstein

    •

    Jan 3, 2023

    Adding to this a default to collapsed threads, with an option to see the whole thread. See picture below.

    Longer threads get very hard to scroll past on mobile!

  • Dr. Lynyetta Willis

    •

    Dec 20, 2022

    Yes please especially for the latter request!!

    Posts and comments in my community are long! You have to scroll for days to get to the next comment. PLEASE implement the ability for thread posts and comments to auto collapse similar to FB. That way you can click a “see more” link to expand the comments you’re interested in reading. It looks better overall and is easier on the eyes when scrolling.